Skip to main content
Back to all projects
Dispute ResolutionSaudi Arabia

Supplier Dispute Mediation — USD 900k Equipment Procurement, KSA

Technical-commercial mediation of a supplier's USD 600,000 claim on a USD 900,000 equipment order — settled at USD 93,000 in two working days, with fabrication restarted and the specified equipment kept.

Case study published 21 October 2026

Location
Saudi Arabia
Duration
2-day negotiation
End Client
Saudi manufacturing facility (name withheld)
Role

Specifications · Tender & Bid Evaluation · Claim Review · Negotiation

Case study PDFÉtude de cas (FR)

USD 900k
Original order
USD 600k
Supplier claim
USD 93k
Agreed settlement
2 days
To agreement
Project Background

The context that shaped the engineering.

In 2009, Eng. Naim led the technical specifications, tender documents and technical bid evaluation for advanced industrial equipment required by a major Saudi manufacturing facility. Seven suppliers bid. A US-based supplier approved by Saudi Aramco was selected for its technical compliance and competitive price, with a purchase order of about USD 900,000, and fabrication began after kick-off. Around four months into fabrication, the supplier suspended work, replaced its project manager and demanded a further USD 600,000 — about 67% of the order — claiming that many requirements were outside the agreed scope. It refused to resume work until paid. A long-lead, high-technology procurement now faced delay, possible replacement costs and legal escalation.
Scope of Services

What was delivered.

01

Specifications & Tender

Technical specifications, tender documents and technical bid evaluation across seven suppliers — the record the dispute was later settled on.

02

Claim Review

Each of the 30+ claimed additional items checked against the specifications, bid clarifications, meeting records and correspondence.

03

Root-Cause Assessment

Commercial review of why the supplier stopped work: a bid priced below what the specified components cost, not a change of scope.

04

Settlement Design

A reasoned USD 93,000 accommodation, split so the client could approve it without a lengthy board process.

Design Solution

How the engineering came together.

Integrated multidisciplinary delivery

The negotiation took place in a third country, with the client's management in the room. Eng. Naim brought the specifications, bid clarifications, meeting records, correspondence and written confirmations from the supplier's former project manager, and went through the supplier's 30+ claimed items one by one. Almost all had been explicitly included or resolved during bidding and clarification; only USD 12,000 was accepted as genuinely additional, and the supplier acknowledged that the scope issues were settled. The supplier then admitted that its former project manager had badly underestimated the manufacturing cost. The specified components were among the best on the market and the original bid had been unusually low, so simply enforcing the price risked a longer suspension and greater exposure for the client. Eng. Naim proposed a USD 93,000 accommodation: the USD 12,000 legitimate item plus USD 81,000 of commercially justified support. The client could approve only USD 40,000 as a contract variation without a lengthy board process, so he split it — USD 40,000 as a variation and USD 53,000 as separately defined additional works. The full USD 93,000 was agreed and approved, bringing the order to about USD 993,000.

From proving scope to solving the real problem

Winning the scope argument was not enough to finish the project. The supplier's real problem was an underpriced bid, so the settlement paid only for what was legitimate or commercially justified — and was structured so the client could approve it quickly.

Key Outcomes

The results the client took to operations.

USD 507,000 Avoided

The supplier's USD 600,000 demand settled at USD 93,000 — 84.5% less, limiting the increase to about 10.3% of the original order.

Project Back on Track

Agreement reached in two intensive working days; fabrication resumed and the schedule was protected.

Specified Equipment Kept

The high-performance equipment chosen in the tender was preserved — no re-tender and no replacement supplier.

No International Dispute

Escalation into a costly cross-border contract dispute was avoided.

Disciplines Covered

Multidisciplinary by design.

Technical-Commercial MediationContract Scope VerificationSupplier NegotiationChange-Order AssessmentProcurement & TenderingProject Recovery
Need this capability?

The services behind this project, explained in depth.

Your project

Have a similar engineering problem on your asset?

Send the brief — Eng. Naim replies personally with a discovery-call invitation and a short qualification questionnaire.